Hundreds call for unfccc to end support for okhla incinerator in delhi global alliance for incinerator alternatives electricity jeopardy 4th grade


The Clean Development Mechanism’s flagship waste management project in India, the Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Co Pvt. Ltd, has turned into a multi-faceted disaster. electricity jokes puns Flaws in both the carbon credit mechanism as well as the corporate driven, technology-focused approach to climate change mitigation, has failed the people of India and trashed the reputation of the UNFCCC and its CDM.

“It is unfortunate that there is such blatant fraud on the UNFCCC’s carbon credit mechanism as well as on the conditions on which the environment clearance was granted by Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, India” said Umesh C. Bahri, a resident of Sukhdev Vihar and a scientist familiar with accreditation processes. “While both entities have been notified of the fraud, no action has been taken by either bodies or by the NGT.”

The public-private partnership based Jindal conglomerate owned Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Co Pty Ltd, claims it to be “one of the first and largest integrated waste management projects ever set up in the country, aiming for a sustainable waste management solution by taking MSW through an environmentally friendly process to generate clean and renewable energy. The project boasts a so called “state-of-the-art facility which offers a safe, technologically advanced means of waste disposal while also generating clean, renewable energy, reducing greenhouse gases and in particular methane gas emissions and supporting recycling through the recovery of metals and other recyclable materials.” [2]We point to the lived experience

of the vulnerable host communities affected by this disastrous project. electricity explained For several years now, the residents of SukhdevVihar, Delhi, living in the shadow of this waste to energy incinerator plant have been engaged in litigation over the feasibility, use of technology and pollution being caused by the plant. As far back as 2009, residents took the matter to the Delhi High Court [1]claiming that the plant was emitting dioxins and heavy metals; the matter was heard 27 times in the High Court. In February 2013, the case was shifted to the National Green Tribunal (NGT- India’s fast track court for environmental related cases) where there have been more than 50 hearings since and still counting.

The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) granted technology approval for the establishment of an integrated Municipal Solid Waste Plant (MSWP) with two Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) plants, a bio-methanation plant and a power plant. However, the project was set up with no facilities for the generation of RDF (ie pellets or brickettes) or Bio-methanation. electricity in the body causes Instead the proponent has used reciprocating stoker type boilers of Chinese origin, the use of which is being phased out in even in China following widespread public protest. The Guangzhou Boiler Group which manufactures the stoker-type boilers has installed the equipment at Okhla plant. [3]

Regulatory agencies of the state have also issued the project proponent a show cause notice [4]and denied it authorisation or consent to operate during the last monitoring period (2012 – 2015). Regulators (Central Pollution Control Board of India) have informed the relevant court via affidavit that there have been complete alterations with respect to the description of the project as approved in the said Environmental Clearance.

“Climate change is about justice and sustainability, not about poisoning people and snatching away livelihoods. But this is what the Okhla waste-to-energy plant has done-displace nearly 300 waste pickers, and consequently, 63% of their children out of school. For this, it has received carbon credits. electricity billy elliot lyrics Is this how the world will fight climate change? By funding poverty creation? The new climate finance regime must put decent, sustainable livelihoods and the poor at its centre rather than expect technologies alone to make the world cooler.” ~ Bharati Chaturvedi, Director, Chintan, Delhi

Despite such a long tainted record for this incinerator plant, the UNFCCC has issued a total ofEven as recent as the 6th July 2016 meeting [5] called under the Chairmanship of Chief Secretary, Government of National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi to implement the orders of the National Green Tribunal in the matter of Sukhdev Vihar Residents Welfare Association and Ors Versus State of NCT of Delhi & Ors, notifies that the plant may operate on provisional basis and was ordered to improve its emission standards as per the direction of Delhi Pollution Control Committee and National Green Tribunal.

438,793 CERs between the period 30/03/2011 to 09/03/2016 and will even continue to provide CERs under the CDM until 2021. The plant also blatantly violates other state regulations for polluting industries, being barely 150 meters from long-established residential areas, posing unacceptable health risks [6]to neighbouring residents. In sum 2,000 tonnes of unsegregated municipal waste is being incinerated in this plant daily, causing a serious health hazard to tens of thousands of people living and working in this ecologically-sensitive area. Two major hospitals in the area have also complained to the prime minister’s office about the hazards to patients [7].

The city of Delhi, which hosts this facility, has effectively become a dangerous, high risk, air pollution zone. The levels of PM2.5 pollutants, which are the most harmful because they can deposit deep into the lungs and cross the blood-brain barrier, have reached at least 999 ppm in the city this week, more than 16 times the safe limit of 60ppm. [8]

climate solutions that rely on burning organics and recyclable materials for comparatively low energy value. youtube electricity Waste to energy incinerators displace more effective Zero Waste practices that create jobs and preserve the materials in our waste stream for future use and are comparatively more cost effective. They also displace cleaner renewable energy technologies such as solar, wind and wave power, anaerobic digesters and biogas plants, while entrenching a globally destructive and unsustainable linear economic model.

While incinerators have aroused serious concerns worldwide and their impacts on human health have been extensively documented, the CDM continues to support their expansion, with little regard for their impact on recycling rates and the GHG reduction benefits associated, and without requiring any other pollution controls. It is time for the UNFCCC to recognize that it cannot ensure the environmental integrity of incinerators and their associated toxic ash residue stockpiles, nor eliminate the social harm that they cause. Rather than continuing to support projects with negative social and environmental outcomes, the CDM should cease issuing CERs to solid waste disposal projects, including all forms of waste to energy incinerators and landfills.Furthermore, the assumptions underlying greenhouse gas reduction estimations made under the CDM, do not take into account the considerable GHG reductions achieved by the current informal recycling sector. For instance, Delhi’s waste-pickers are responsible for annual emissions reductions of approximately 962,133 tCO2e [9]through recycling. If the waste to energy project burns even one-quarter of Delhi’s recyclables, it will effectively wipe out its own emissions savings, resulting in no net emissions reductions. But because the CDM has not calculated the project’s impact on recycling, it will continue to award the company hundreds of thousands of spurious carbon credits – credits which do not represent real emissions reductions.

With this compelling evidence before you, we urge you to categorically exclude waste to energy incinerators and landfill projects from eligibility for carbon credits. These waste disposal methods, which destroy finite resources and generate significant toxic and greenhouse gas emissions, have no place in the CDM. They compete with waste reduction, reuse, recycling, and composting — all of which are, according to the waste hierarchy, superior over land filling and incineration.

to ensure compliance with the current CDM modalities and procedures. gas utility bill Such investigation must include a full human health and environmental impact assessment, in cooperation with state and local authorities and with the full inclusion of all stakeholders to ascertain the harm this project has caused to the community and their environment. Should the CDM Board find that the plant is not compliant and is in fact causing adverse health impacts on the community then it should immediately withdraw the project from the CDM list.