New emissions reporting standard just hot air local news gas dryer vs electric dryer cost savings


The original requirement to report air emissions arises from two environmental laws designed to support emergency planning efforts. The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, known by its acronym CERCLA, and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, called EPCRA, require entities to report releases of hazardous substances that rise above a certain threshold within a 24-hour period.

The laws’ purpose is to help federal, state and local officials evaluate whether they need to take emergency actions to mitigate the effects of such releases, according to a page on the EPA’s website discussing the reporting requirements under the two laws.

But the EPA doesn’t believe there is anything practical that federal officials should do in response to emissions from animal feeding operations, like dairy or hog farms. In a rule the agency created in 2008, it stopped requiring small farmers to report air emissions, though CAFOs — concentrated animal feeding operations, such as dairy farms with 700 or more cows — still had to report under EPCRA.

That regulatory policy was overturned in April 2017 after environmental groups challenged it in court. If left in place, it would have saved farms more than a million hours and more than $60 million in costs over a decade, as well as saving the federal government roughly 160,000 hours and $8 million in related costs, the court acknowledged in its ruling.

An initial deadline for the EPA to start requiring reports was extended until May 1 of this year. Now, the National Milk Producers Federation and others in the agricultural industry are lobbying lawmakers to change the law to bring that exception back.

“CERCLA was never intended to be applied in this way to dairy farms,” the president and CEO of the National Milk Producers Federation, Jim Mulhern, said in a press release from the industry group. “Congress needs to stipulate that this burdensome regulatory overreach serves no legitimate health or safety purpose, and needs to stop.”

Andy and Janet Dague, Kewanna, raise about 250 milk cows on their family farm in southern Fulton County, collecting their cows’ waste to use as fertilizer on their grain fields. The couple took over from Andy’s grandparents, who bought the farm in the 1960s. Besides the cows and four dairy beef, the family has more than a dozen goats their 16-year-old daughter raises, plus some ponies and horses their children enter in the local 4-H fair.

They employ three or four people part-time, including another family member. Their day starts at 5 a.m., milking the cows and carrying out farm chores until about 10 a.m. Activity slows a bit until close to the afternoon milking, starting around 3 p.m. Chores might be wrapped up for the day around 7 p.m.

“I tried to look up some information and there’s not a whole lot out there,” Andy Dague said. Existing regulations surrounding small farms like theirs are fairly minimal, he said, and don’t amount to too much more than any self-employed business owner in the food industry would need to abide by.

The agency indicates in fact sheets that it can’t flat-out say farms having, say, 600 dairy cows must report emissions — emissions depend not only on the number and type of animals, but on other factors like geographic location, environmental conditions and farm management practices. Furthermore, the EPA acknowledged “it will be challenging for farmers to estimate releases because there is no generally accepted methodology for estimating these emissions at this time.” It provides links to several resources to help farmers estimate their own farms’ emissions.

It states on its website that farmers aren’t required to reduce emissions if they rise above the reportable threshold. The agency also doesn’t require farmers to actually monitor their emissions — only that they provide reasonable estimates.

But since Congressional lawmakers including Indiana Sen. Joe Donnelly have introduced a bill to permanently exempt farmers from CERCLA reporting requirements — the Fair Agriculture Reporting Method, or FARM Act — Andy Dague says he doesn’t intend to stress about it.