The ongoing campaign linear fighters, quadratic magic-users gaslighting examples

###########

A big complaint some people have about the way that game is balanced is that Magic-Users increase in power at an increasing rate throughout their careers, while Fighters tend to increase steadily. This is formulated as the Fighter improving on a linear basis, while the Magic-User improves on a quadratic basis. It certainly does seem like a conundrum, since Gary Gygax was writing AD&D on the basis of many, many hours spent running the game at a real table, for hundreds of players. electricity billy elliot broadway How could he have missed something so obvious?

Gary knew that Fighters and Magic-Users had different focuses for their careers. electricity notes class 10 pdf Each was, after all, a statement by a player about how they wanted to interact with the game and setting. Everyone knows this. The other classes, Cleric, Thief, and so on, are all later attempts by various players to come up with a particular and new way to approach the game and setting, usually based on a particular fictional role model. Clerics were to be Fearless Vampire Slayers in the vein of Van Helsing in the Hammer Dracula films, Thieves were largely the Grey Mouser from Fritz Leiber’s stories (and, yes, a little bit of Vance’s Cugel the Clever too), Monks were an attempt to model Shaw Brothers wuxia films, Rangers were Strider/Aragorn. k gas station Later, the Barbarian was to be Conan.

The Cleric, of course, would be a fantasy Bishop, in charge of a holy temple with all of the attendants that implied, as well as believing peasants who would provide an income through their labor. This reminds me that AD&D is also explicit that the majority of the world does not have a class or level, and so most religious leaders are probably not able to cast spells, though perhaps more people who are able to are drawn to holy orders and so there would be more than among the general populace. But I digress.

Which means that Fighters should probably also have a body of laborers to protect in exchange for tax monies. Like, I would say, a noble. And what is the source of a noble’s power? The number of swords they can command. gas vs electric heat And that is exactly what a high-level fighter gets access to: a loyal troop. But they only get this power if they pursue it by clearing a barony of sorts. electricity nw This is where many players lose the plot. There is a perception that only hardscrabble adventuring is fun, that the logistics of running a small domain make the game bog down into boredom.

But D&D was a wargame first, and the people who played it were wargamers at heart. For many, the whole point of play was to get to where they could command fantasy troops. Exercising power means dealing with other power-brokers in the setting, which means more opportunities for adventure, not fewer, since a baron can surely equip an expedition into a ruined castle, but murderhoboes can’t usually broker deals that affect the lives of thousands or more.

It is true that an individual Magic-User up against an individual Fighter will have a great advantage, with some abilities that the Fighter will have difficulty countering. gas pedal lyrics That said, AD&D introduced a system whereby a Fighter could prevent the Magic-User from casting by interrupting the ritual. In addition, there were requirements for material components, as well as motions and words, that made the Magic-User’s job a little more difficult. Adding these together, along with the overwhelming power of masses—one thing that people learn quickly when designing wargames rules that attempt to duplicate the D&D combat system on a mass scale is that even the most powerful of heroes will have a hard time against tens or hundreds of opponents. o goshi Swords & Spells, Battlesystem, and others found that they had to emphasize the abilities of heroic individuals, or alternatively games like Delta’s Book of War learned that most D&D "heroes" weren’t even worth representing on the battlefield as separate figures. Even powers like a Magic-User’s spells, which seem overwhelming at the individual scale, turn out to have only small effect at the battle scale—enough, to be sure, to be worth simulating, but they only steer a battle in relatively subtle ways.

Myself, I think that a character should get experience for the money that they take in by taxing their domain. gas density of air This encourages them to expand their domain and keep it safe from threats, since the more people they protect directly affects their experience gains. That would also encourage players to play the endgame for its adventuresome qualities instead of avoiding it in favor of more dungeon-delving, murderhobo adventures. More likely, these days, I’ll simply give players experience for money spent rather than collected, but I won’t make any distinctions about where they got it.

3G (1) ACKS (4) actual play (4) AD&D (1) administrivia (15) Adventures Dark and Deep (7) alternate campaign frames (5) Black Blood of the Earth (11) blogiversary (2) Bunnies and Burrows (1) character class (13) Chivalry & Sorcery (2) combat (9) CORPS (5) curses (1) Deindustrial Future (5) design (29) dice (1) Dungeons and Dragons (45) EABA (1) Fading Empire (2) Faerie Queene (4) Fantasy Wargaming (23) Fantasy West (8) FBI Guide (9) fiction (2) Flanaess Sector (9) Flashing Blades (6) fun (75) futurism (2) gaming philosophy (48) general philosophy (7) goals (9) Goth of the Week (56) GURPS (26) GURPS Greyhawk (8) GURPS Martial Arts (2) GURPS Traveller (4) GURPS Voodoo (10) Hard Times On The Solomani Rim (1) Hârnmaster (7) Hearth (2) HeroQuest (2) High Colonies (1) holidays (4) House Rules (2) ideas (33) inspiration (18) intro (3) Kickstarter (6) Lands Of Adventure (2) Legendary Lives (1) Lords of Creation (2) magic (15) Mandragora (1) maps (5) measures (1) megadungeons (3) MegaTraveller (23) Middle Sea (20) miniatures (3) MOHb (2) monsters (3) movies (7) music video (6) NaNoWriMo (4) obscure games (28) Other Blogs (13) Pendragon (6) plans (5) projects (26) psionics (2) Quick NPCs (3) random tables (1) Ray Harryhausen (1) Real-Time Traveller (1) Realms of the Unknown (2) recommendations (12) Referee hints (6) religion (9) resources (9) RPG business (7) RuneQuest (7) science fantasy (11) science fiction (6) Space 1889 (2) SpaceTime (1) Spectacular Science Stories (9) stats (6) Striker (1) structure (12) Sundaland (3) Supergame (1) Swordbearer (5) Swords and Wizardry (10) taking a poll (11) Tales of the Space Princess (1) television (1) Terra Ultima (13) The Arcanum (2) TimeLords (1) Top Secret (17) Trait System (3) Traveller (22) Traveller: The New Era (4) Traveller5 (1) Tunnels and Trolls (1) Unknown Armies (1) Villains and Vigilantes (10) wargames (1) warning (3) WarpWorld (1) whining (3) White Star (3) worldbuilding (51) WotC (5) WRG game (14) zines (2)