Two duval students who opted out of state tests allege retaliation

One parent said she was told her child may have to repeat third grade, while another said her future freshman is being kept out of an early college program.

It’s happening around the state, says Sandy Stenoff, a founder of The Opt Out Florida Network, a coalition of more than 40 parent-led groups opposed to Florida’s Standards Assessments, which replaced the old FCAT exams at the beginning of the last school year.

It is unclear how many students opted not to take the tests or how many are being held back as a result; districts and the state say they’re not counting.

The state says at least 224 third-grade reading tests had too few answers on them to be scored, but Stenoff said she believes many more students than that opted out.

“Many 8-year-old children whose parents opted them out of the spring FSA are being threatened with retention by their schools and districts, simply because they have no test score,” Stenoff wrote in the group’s blog. Gas and bloating pain “This is happening, even as the schools admit that these children have no documented reading deficiencies.”

State education officials maintain that there is no legal way to opt out of state testing. Find a gas station close to me They say they’re not causing these retaliations, that decisions about grade promotion are left up to school districts.

But school district officials say state law ties their hands. 10 gases and their uses It stipulates that they can offer parents only a few alternatives if students opted out, including other forms of testing.

“I respect a parent’s right to opt out, but they must be prepared to assist their child through one of these alternatives,” said Duval Superintendent Nikolai Vitti. Gas in back symptoms “That is state policy, not district policy. Physics c electricity and magnetism Arguing with the district regarding the alternatives is futile.”

Isabella is bright student, receiving mostly B’s on her report card this year from Crown Point Elementary and proficient scores in Duval’s own reading and math tests, said Amy Hynes, her mother.

Like her three older siblings, Isabella chose to “minimally participate” in the FSA tests earlier this year, meaning she went to school on test days, signed her name on the tests but did not answer any questions.

Hynes said her other children also have not taken state tests in recent years, because the family believes the tests are misused to unfairly judge teachers while warping school curriculum into test-prep sessions. 76 gas credit card account login This is the first time one of her children was going to be punished for opting out, Hynes said.

“Our main point is we trust our teachers,” Hynes said. Electricity electricity music notes “If a teacher has spent 180 days with her and she says there’s no reading deficiency, I think that should work for them.”

Vitti pointed out students who don’t have passing scores in the FSA reading test can still take an alternative test called the SAT 10 or their teachers can compile a “portfolio.”

The state’s portfolio requirement mandates that student work include three demonstrations of mastering each state standard for reading and that 60 percent of the reading passages be nonfiction and average about 500 words.

Some districts, like Duval, made up their own portfolio “tests” to meet these requirements, but some parents say they are against this, too, because these amount to worksheets or multiple mini tests.

Hynes said since the first week of school she and Isabella’s teachers have maintained a portfolio including all of her daughter’s work, but until recently district officials didn’t look at it.

Monday, Hynes said she was notified that Vitti will allow the family to submit “an authentic portfolio” of Isabella’s classwork for the past 180 days to a district official before a decision is made on retaining Isabella.

Hynes said she’s keeping finger crossed, while researching her options, including having her daughter privately tested or consulting a lawyer.

Stenoff said other families in the opt out groups have consulted with attorneys in Orange County and Sarasota. Gas calculator No one has filed suit yet, to her knowledge.

Iona Johnson, no relation to Isabella, has been a straight-A, advanced student since elementary school and has taken and scored high in algebra 1 and geometry so far this year at Lake Shore Middle, said Melissa Johnson, her mother. Youtube gas pedal lyrics Her state end-of-course exams for the two math classes are not in.

Melissa Johnson provided a list of Iona’s other scores on Duval County assessments, including a score that appears to indicate Iona reads at a college level. Hp gas online refill booking status In fifth grade, Iona took Florida’s old FCAT tests and scored the top level — Level 5 — on reading, math and science.

Yet Lee High School recently denied Iona entry into its early college program, which would have begun in her ninth grade. Electricity 4th grade worksheet School officials said in emails to Melissa Johnson that they were lacking an FSA score because Iona hadn’t taken the test.

Melissa Johnson pointed out that state education officials and a state-sponsored study of the FSA both indicate that a single score should not be the sole determinant of student-level decisions. Gas 4 weeks pregnant She asked if other tests or scores could be used.

School officials suggested the ACT or SAT, which are college entrance exams usually taken by sophomores, juniors and seniors, not incoming freshmen. Gas 87 89 91 A state official suggested she take a PERT test, another test usually used to determine readiness for college.

“I’m certainly not asking for special treatment for my child, but instead a fair assessment,” she said. Gasset y ortega filosofia “I would hope and certainly think a school would welcome strong students, not turn them away.”

“Just to be clear, we do not condone as a district any retaliation against students or parents at any school if they make a decision to opt out,” he said. Gas bubble retinal detachment “However, at the same time, parents need to understand that certain follow-up steps need to be maintained and enforced to allow the student to move on to fourth grade, graduate from high school with a standard high school diploma, or be scheduled for certain courses the following year at the secondary level.”